Choosing Your Supervisory Stance: When to advise, ask, challenge or support
About the session
Supervisors move among several legitimate positions: disciplinary expert, mentor, challenger, supporter, coach and institutional representative. Drawing selectively on Transactional Analysis, this
session explores how supervisors can slip into habitual relational positions and what these positions may invite from the researcher. Participants consider how to recognise the stance they are taking and choose more deliberately when to advise, challenge, support, or leave responsibility with the researcher in response to the person and situation.
This event is part of the series called Coaching-Informed Conversations for Doctoral Supervision.
About the series
Doctoral supervisor development regularly focuses on the responsibilities and procedures of supervision: institutional requirements, roles, milestones, feedback, progress, and difficult situations. These are essential. Yet supervision is also shaped by something less procedural: the disposition a supervisor brings to the conversation – what they assume, what they listen for, how quickly they move to solve, how they use expertise and authority, and how much space they create for a researcher to think.
This coaching-informed series develops that less visible dimension of practice. It shifts attention from supervision only as a set of tasks to the way a supervisor is present and relates within the conversation, and how this shapes when they advise, ask, challenge, support, or step back. The aim is not to turn supervisors into coaches or replace disciplinary expertise, but to help them use their expertise more deliberately while supporting researcher judgement, confidence, and ownership.


